It’s no secret that the economic downturn affects everyone. Figuring out how is another matter altogether.
For the third time this year, eMarketer has lowered its online advertising spending estimates. Yet the company reports online spending on the whole will increase 8.9% over 2009 (in fact, eight key areas — search, display ads, video, rich media, classifieds, leads generation, sponsorships and email — are estimated to see increases in spending).
This would be great news — if it were true. I’m not sure what kind of rose-colored calculator eMarketer uses for its projections, but the numbers we’re seeing paint a far grimmer picture.
Pubmatic, an online ad optimization services, reported that 2008 Q4 CPMs were down a full 48% from the year before. At a time when you’d expect the numbers to rise with consumers toting around shopping bags full of holiday gifts, these lower numbers do not speak well for the year ahead. The company also reported that ad spending on entertainment sites plummeted 42% in the past year.
So what can we expect to see in 2009?
SEM spending will be flat. Why? Tightening budgets, lower CPCs and a decrease in a number of competitors due to bankruptcy. Compared to other demand generation vehicles, this cost-effective approach should weather the financial storm and provide marketers with the justifiable spending they seek. JP Morgan predicts search spending will increase 23.4% in 2009. We believe that number is very optimistic.
Display ad spending will fall sharply. Until someone develops a model that can deliver the rich, branded content of display ads at CPC prices of search ads, marketers should be wary of the high cost of banner ads. Springbox anticipates a large online ad network will change to a cost-per-click model in 2009 in order to generate new value from a rapidly declining asset.
Social media will offer new opportunities for customer engagement. As an alternative to display ads, social media spending may well increase. Marketers will incorporate these tools into their arsenal as a way to understand how consumers view their brands. Improved tracking of visitor engagement along the purchase path will enable marketers to quantify the value of their social networking efforts.
The current financial climate is the perfect time for marketers to take stock of their marketing plans. Every line item — traditional or digital — should be working together to drive conversion and add brand value.
Thanks to Robert Raiford for contributing valuable insight to this article.